MERBAU VS COMPOSITE VS TIMBER DECKING: WHAT'S ACTUALLY WORTH IT FOR A PERTH HOME?
- Mounts Bay Constructions
- 6 days ago
- 5 min read
Your deck takes more punishment than any other surface on your property. Perth's UV index regularly hits extreme levels. Salt air drifts inland further than most people realize. And that beautiful Merbau everyone's been installing? It's been leaving rust-coloured stains on limestone walls and pool surrounds across the western suburbs for years.
Choosing decking isn't about picking what looks best in the showroom. It's about understanding how materials behave in our specific climate—and how much time you're willing to spend maintaining them over the next decade.
THE TANNIN PROBLEM NOBODY TALKS ABOUT UNTIL IT'S TOO LATE
Walk through any established Perth neighbourhood and you'll spot the telltale signs: reddish-brown streaks down rendered walls, discoloured pavers, stained pool copings. Merbau's tannin bleed is particularly aggressive, releasing water-soluble extractives for months—sometimes years—after installation.
This isn't a defect. It's the natural behaviour of timber extractives when exposed to moisture. But in Perth, where we get all our rain in winter followed by nine months of intense sun, that seasonal cycle creates perfect conditions for ongoing tannin release.
Tannin Bleed Risk Comparison
Material | Bleed Risk | Duration | Staining Severity | Management Required |
Merbau | High | 6-24 months | Severe - rust-red staining on all adjacent surfaces | Intensive - multiple washes, oxalic acid treatment |
Blackbutt | Low-Medium | 2-4 weeks | Mild - light brown marks | Minimal - initial weathering only |
Spotted Gum | Low | 1-2 weeks | Minimal - slight discolouration | None after initial wash |
Composite | None | Not applicable | No staining | No management needed |
Treated Pine | Very Low | 1 week | Negligible | Single wash if any |
The science behind timber leaching shows that tropical hardwoods like Merbau contain significantly higher levels of water-soluble extractives than Australian natives. These extractives are what give Merbau its natural durability—but they're also what will stain your limestone for the next two summers.
THE REAL COST OF OWNERSHIP IN PERTH'S CLIMATE
Most quotes focus on supply and installation. But in our high-UV environment, maintenance costs can exceed the original installation price within a decade. Here's what the numbers actually look like when you factor in Perth's specific conditions:
True Cost Comparison (Perth Market 2024)
Material | Supply Cost/m² | Installed Cost/m² | Annual Maintenance | 10-Year Maintenance Cost | Total 10-Year Ownership |
Merbau | $200-250 | $15-20/m² | $150-200/m² | $350-450/m² | |
Premium Hardwood | $100-150 | $15-20/m² | $150-200/m² | $450-600/m² | |
Treated Pine | $40-60 | $20-25/m² | $200-250/m² | $400-500/m² | |
Composite (Premium) | $2-5/m² | $20-50/m² | $270-500/m² |
Note: Maintenance costs include materials and labour for oiling, sanding, and repairs. Perth's extreme UV accelerates oil breakdown, requiring more frequent recoating than eastern states.
UNDERSTANDING MATERIAL BEHAVIOUR IN WA CONDITIONS
Perth presents unique challenges that don't exist in Sydney or Melbourne. We're dealing with nine months of intense UV exposure, winter rain that arrives all at once, and coastal salt that affects properties 20 kilometres from the beach.
Composite decking has evolved significantly from the plastic-looking boards of a decade ago. Modern composites use wood fibres and polymer caps that handle our UV levels without the constant maintenance cycle timber demands.
Maintenance Reality Check
Material | First Year | Years 2-5 | Years 6-10 | Owner Time Commitment |
Merbau | Oil 3x, wash tannins monthly | Oil 2x annually, sand every 2 years | Oil 2x annually, replace boards as needed | 40+ hours annually |
Blackbutt/Spotted Gum | Oil 2x | Oil annually | Oil annually, sand every 3 years | 20 hours annually |
Composite | Wash once | Wash annually | Wash annually | 2 hours annually |
Treated Pine | Oil 3x, possible twist/warp | Oil 2x annually, replace warped boards | Major restoration or replacement likely | 30+ hours annually |
The comparison between timber and composite isn't just about aesthetics anymore. It's about understanding your tolerance for maintenance versus your desire for natural materials.
LONGEVITY & WARRANTY: WHAT'S ACTUALLY GUARANTEED
Warranty coverage reveals what manufacturers really believe about their products' performance in Australian conditions:
Warranty and Lifespan Comparison
Material | Structural Warranty | Fade/Stain Warranty | Realistic Lifespan (Perth) | Replacement Triggers |
Merbau | None (natural product) | Not applicable | 15-20 years with maintenance | Rot, splitting, severe weathering |
Australian Hardwood | None (natural product) | Not applicable | 20-25 years with maintenance | Structural degradation |
Treated Pine | Up to 25 years (in-ground) | Not applicable | 8-12 years | Warping, splintering, rot |
Premium Composite | 25 years | 25-30 years | Unlikely within warranty period |
These aren't theoretical numbers. They're based on actual performance in WA's climate, where UV degradation happens 30% faster than the Australian average.
MAKING THE RIGHT CHOICE FOR YOUR PROPERTY
Choosing between timber and composite comes down to three factors that matter more than initial aesthetics:
Choose Merbau if:
You love the natural timber look and feel
You're committed to regular maintenance
Tannin staining won't affect adjacent surfaces
You have the budget for ongoing upkeep
Choose Composite if:
Low maintenance is a priority
You have a pool or light-coloured surrounds
Long-term cost matters more than upfront price
You want guaranteed performance for 20+ years
Choose Alternative Timbers if:
You want natural timber without tannin issues
You prefer Australian species
You're willing to maintain but want to avoid Merbau's staining
Your property suits the silver-grey weathered look
THE SUSTAINABILITY QUESTION
Modern composite decking contains up to 95% recycled content—reclaimed wood fibres and recycled plastic that would otherwise go to landfill. Quality timber comes from managed forests, but the oils and treatments required for maintenance carry their own environmental load.
The most sustainable choice? The one that lasts longest with the least intervention.
WORKING WITH PERTH'S ENVIRONMENT, NOT AGAINST IT
Your deck faces challenges that indoor flooring never will. Salt, sun, rain—they're all working to break down whatever material you choose. The question isn't whether your deck will weather. It's how gracefully it will age and how much effort you'll put in to slow that process.
Smart orientation matters as much as material choice. North-facing decks in Perth cop full sun from October to March. West-facing spaces get blasted every summer afternoon. These exposures accelerate weathering by up to 40% compared to protected southern aspects.
A MORE CONSIDERED WAY TO FUND YOUR OUTDOOR UPGRADE
There’s also a quieter shift happening among Perth homeowners who want to elevate their outdoor spaces without waiting years to accumulate capital. Instead of delaying their project, they’re approaching their decking investment the same way they approach every other part of their home — with strategy.
Many are using HUMM Financing as a way to pace the spend intelligently. The deck gets built now, while shade structures, lighting or screening are added in later seasons — each stage completed when it makes the most sense for their lifestyle and cash flow.
It’s not about taking on unnecessary debt. It’s about sequencing your outdoor upgrade so you can enjoy the improvements immediately, rather than waiting for the “perfect moment” that rarely arrives. The result is a calm, measured approach: a space that evolves gracefully, and a budget that remains under control.
BEYOND MATERIAL SELECTION
The best deck for your property might not be what your neighbour installed. Your block's orientation, your maintenance tolerance, your aesthetic preferences, and your long-term plans all factor into the equation.
That's why we begin every deck project with a comprehensive site evaluation. We assess sun exposure, prevailing winds, soil conditions, drainage patterns, and how you actually intend to use the space.
It's not about selling you the most expensive option. It's about identifying the solution that will perform best on your specific block, within your maintenance comfort zone, and aligned with your investment goals.
Ready to explore what makes sense for your property? Let's start with a design consultation that examines your site's unique conditions, your lifestyle needs, and the real costs of each option over the next decade. We'll help you understand not just what to build, but why it's the right choice for your Perth home.
Comments